Corpus Plan

For agencies and freelancers

How to explain a GEO audit to a client

A GEO audit can tell your client whether AI assistants are able to fetch, read and cite their website. It can't give a stable number for whether ChatGPT mentions them, because those answers change from day to day. Say that first, and the rest of the call gets easier.

We make Corpus Plan, a GEO audit tool, so we have a stake in this topic. Where we describe our own tool, we say so, and every outside source is linked and dated at the bottom.

Why clients are asking now

Agencies say the question is no longer rare. Asked on r/SEO whether clients were asking about ChatGPT, one agency replied that it "went from occasional to every monthly call in the last 3 months." [6] The hard part is that "AI visibility" is sold in very different ways.

One mid-market buyer on Reddit sat through six pitches for AI search visibility services in one month. Every agency had its own "visibility score." When asked how it was calculated, two said they couldn't share without an NDA, and three "basically said 'we ask the LLMs a bunch of prompts and count how often you appear.'" [1] A commenter on the same thread put it more bluntly: most AI visibility scores right now are "prompt-counting dressed up as measurement." [1]

Your client may have heard those pitches too. The way to stand apart is to be precise about what you checked.

What a GEO audit can measure today

A GEO audit measures the site, not the AI answer. These are things you can check today and get the same result if you check again:

  • Can AI crawlers get in? Does robots.txt block the crawlers that fetch pages for live answers, such as OAI-SearchBot or PerplexityBot? Blocking those is a citability problem. Blocking training-only crawlers such as GPTBot is a separate, deliberate choice.
  • Can they read the page? Is the main copy in the HTML, or does it only appear after JavaScript runs?
  • Are the facts structured? Does the site use structured data (JSON-LD) to state who the business is and what it does?
  • Is the content shaped like an answer? Are there question headings, short direct answers, lists and tables an assistant can quote?
  • Are the SEO basics in place? Titles, headings, indexing, speed and trust signals. AI assistants mostly cite pages that search engines can already find and read. ChatGPT traffic starts with SEO covers this.

None of these prove an assistant will cite the site. They show whether anything is stopping it.

What it can't measure

  • Whether an assistant names the business. Single checks are unstable. See the next section.
  • Leads or revenue. An audit describes the site on the day it ran.
  • Cause and effect. One agency described a client asking for proof that their GEO work caused an improvement. The owner wrote that they could "show correlation pretty easily," but that claiming the GEO work caused the increase felt dishonest. [2] Content updates, new mentions and regular SEO work all happened in the same period. An audit can't separate those, and you shouldn't claim it can.

Why AI visibility scores flip

The most detailed public data we found comes from an SEO who is building a tracking tool, and who said so up front. They asked 16 buying questions about one electrician in the Vancouver area every morning for 32 days, across ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AI Mode, AI Overviews and, for the last two weeks, Perplexity, and logged 1,814 answers. [3] What they reported:

  • On the same morning, the systems agreed only 1 time in 5, even with a generous definition of "agreed."
  • Each system also disagreed with itself. On 29–37% of days, its answer named no business in common with its own answer the day before.
  • The business flipped between named and not named on 9–17% of consecutive days, with nothing changed on its site.

The author lists the limits: one business, one trade, one city. Still, a commenter drew the obvious conclusion: "the 9-17% flip rate with no site changes is what would worry me if i were advising a client. hard to optimize for something that unstable." [3]

A builder of another tracking product (also disclosed) gave one reason on Hacker News: "the variance in LLM responses based on temperature and system prompt updates makes consistency a major hurdle for this type of monitoring." The same comment separates two cases. A model may fetch your site live, which site structure and indexing can influence. Or it may answer from older training data, which you can't change until the model is retrained. [4]

What this means for your report: a mention count from one run is a sample, not a measurement. If you show one, label the date, the assistant, the number of questions and how many times you ran them. The agency quoted above does this by hand: a fixed set of 20 category questions, with no brand in the prompt, run 3 times each month. [6] Even then, don't present it as a score that went up or down because of your work.

What "couldn't verify" means, and why you want it

Some checks can't finish. A firewall answers instead of the site, or a request times out. A good audit says so instead of guessing.

In Corpus Plan's audit, a check that can't collect its evidence is marked Couldn't verify. It emits no finding, and the signal is dropped from the score, so it can neither help nor hurt. [5] Here is how one looks on our own site's report:

AI-crawler access: Couldn't verify. No robots.txt rule blocks the AI crawlers, but this audit has no record of fetching the homepage as the AI crawlers. A CDN or firewall block is not ruled out.

For a client call, this matters. You never have to defend a result the tool made up. You can say: "This one didn't complete. I'll confirm it by hand."

How Corpus Plan scores (our tool, our bias)

If you use our GEO audit, this is what you can tell a client about the number, all of it from our published methodology: [5]

  • Five pillars, including AI citability, then SEO, speed, trust and content. Each is scored 0–100. AI citability and SEO each carry 25% of the overall score, trust 20%, speed and content 15% each. The weights are our judgment, and the methodology says so.
  • Every check, threshold and deduction is published. A critical finding costs 35 points, a major one 15 and a minor one 5.
  • No language model touches a score. A model only phrases the action plan from the findings it is given.
  • The audit is deterministic: the same site on the same day gives the same findings and scores. The one stated exception is a single Google PageSpeed Insights lookup in the speed pillar, which can be unavailable.
  • It reads up to 20 pages. It is not a complete crawl of a large site.

Other tools may work differently. Whatever you use, ask the vendor the same questions: what is checked, what is the threshold, and what happens when a check can't run?

A script for "Are we in ChatGPT?"

Adapt the wording to your client. The order is what matters.

  1. Be straight about the limit. "Nobody can give you a reliable yes or no from one check. AI answers change from day to day, even when nothing on your site changes."
  2. Say what you can answer. "What I can check is whether AI assistants are able to read and cite your site. Here's that report." Send the report link.
  3. Show what's in the way. "These are the things that would stop an assistant from using your site, in the order I'd fix them."
  4. Name what wasn't checked. "Where it says 'couldn't verify', the check didn't complete. I'll confirm those by hand."
  5. Agree how you'll judge results. "For results, let's watch what we can measure: enquiries, referral traffic in your analytics, and asking new customers how they found you."

What not to say: "We'll get you cited," "you'll rank in ChatGPT," or any number that implies you can control what an assistant says.

What to put in the report you send

  • The date the audit ran and the pages it read.
  • What was checked, and what wasn't.
  • Every "couldn't verify" item, with your plan to confirm it.
  • The next three fixes, in order.
  • One plain sentence: "This shows whether your site is ready to be cited. It does not promise that it will be."

Limits of this article

The outside sources are forum posts. The 1,814-answer data covers one business in one city, collected by someone building a tracking tool. Two of the Reddit posts were later removed by moderators. We read them through a public archive and link both the original and the archived copy below. Treat all of this as a field report, not a study.

Run a GEO audit you can explain

Five scored pillars, including AI citability, with every check published. Free preview · no account · no card.

Start free check →

Sources

  1. r/digital_marketing, "Sat through 6 'AI search optimization' pitches this month. They all sell a 'visibility score.' Nobody can explain how it's calculated." Posted 2026-07-02 by a mid-market B2B buyer. Quoted comment by u/No_Trust_645. reddit.com/r/digital_marketing/comments/1ule9bi. Accessed 2026-11-07 via the Arctic Shift archive (post, comment).
  2. r/SEO, "Client wants proof that our GEO work caused the improvement." Posted 2026-09-21. reddit.com/r/SEO/comments/1wmiy5u. Removed by moderators after posting; accessed 2026-11-07 via the Arctic Shift archive (archived copy).
  3. r/SEO, "I tracked 1,814 AI answers for one local business over 32 days…" Posted 2026-10-11 by a self-disclosed tool builder. Quoted comment by u/stonebloomers. reddit.com/r/SEO/comments/1x353ig. Removed by moderators after posting; accessed 2026-11-07 via the Arctic Shift archive (post, comment).
  4. Hacker News comment by nishilbhave, 2026-06-24, who discloses building Sivon HQ, an AI search visibility tracker. news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48660250. Accessed 2026-11-07.
  5. Corpus Plan, "Methodology" (our own page). plan.corpushq.co/methodology. Accessed 2026-11-07.
  6. r/SEO, "Are your clients asking about ChatGPT or AI search visibility yet? How are you handling it?" Posted 2026-10-27. Quoted comment by u/IllustratorSelect290. reddit.com/r/SEO/comments/1xh0g7e. Accessed 2026-11-07 via the Arctic Shift archive (post, comment).